Necessity and safety of completion thyroidectomy for differentiated thyroid carcinoma.

BACKGROUND The diagnosis of thyroid carcinoma during the course of lobectomy for a dominant nodule occasionally cannot be rendered on the basis of frozen section. Once the diagnosis of carcinoma is made, the question of completion thyroidectomy arises. The decision to perform completion thyroidectomy and the timing, safety, and efficacy of this procedure are reviewed. METHODS During the past 25 years (1965 to 1990), we operated on 351 consecutive patients with thyroid carcinoma. One hundred of these patients (84 women and 16 men) were initially treated by unilateral thyroid lobectomy for the previously stated reasons. Histopathologic examination of the permanent sections of the initial thyroid lobectomy specimen demonstrated papillary carcinoma in 70 patients and follicular carcinoma in 30 patients. Within a few months, a completion thyroidectomy was performed. RESULTS The completion thyroidectomy specimen contained papillary carcinoma in 33 (47%) of the 70 patients with papillary carcinoma and 10 (33%) of the 30 patients with follicular carcinoma. Overall, 43 of these 100 patients harbored thyroid carcinoma in the contralateral lobe. Complications of completion thyroidectomy were transient recurrent nerve paresis in two patients and temporary hypoparathyroidism in three patients, requiring calcium and vitamin D therapy for a few months. CONCLUSIONS Although the significance and treatment of papillary carcinoma are debated on the basis of size and grade of the primary lesion and age and sex of the patients, once the diagnosis is made in one lobe we believe that a completion thyroidectomy should be considered, not only for papillary carcinomas but also for follicular carcinomas because 47% (papillary) to 33% (follicular) of these patients will harbor the neoplasm in the contralateral lobe.